Manchester United suffered a dramatic 3-2 defeat to Brighton in the Carabao Cup third-round match at Old Trafford, marking their first early exit from a competition since 1976. The Red Devils, who had taken a 2-0 lead, saw their advantage vanish as Brighton fought back with a second-half brace to secure the victory. The loss has triggered a wave of criticism from fans and pundits alike, with some questioning the team's resilience and defensive solidity.

Manager Michael Carrick accepted responsibility for the defeat, acknowledging the team's struggles in maintaining their lead. Despite the loss, Carrick emphasized that he does not feel under pressure and remains confident in the club's ability to recover. However, the result has raised concerns about the squad's consistency, particularly in high-stakes matches.

Several players, including Leny Yoro and Ayden Heaven, came under fire from former player Jamie Redknapp for their performances. The defeat also intensified discussions about the future of young talent JJ Gabriel, with Carrick addressing the player's potential departure. Fans have expressed frustration, with some turning against the team following the exit.

The loss highlights ongoing challenges for United as they navigate a difficult start to the season. The club will now focus on regrouping and addressing the issues that led to the collapse against Brighton.